Two finalists. One is 34. One is 59.
Same skills. Strong interviews. Good references.
Who gets the offer?
If we’re honest, most hiring managers already know which way they lean.
The part no one says out loud
Age discrimination is illegal. You can’t ask a candidate how old they are.
You don’t need to. The resume that starts in 1989 tells you. So does the gray hair on the video call.
And most of us factor it in. Not on purpose. Not out loud. But it’s there.
Hiring is subjective. There are a hundred reasons to pass on someone.
“Overqualified.”
“Might get bored.”
“Not sure they’d take direction from a younger boss.”
“Too stuck in their ways.”
Each one sounds “fair” I suppose – or does it?
After years of doing this, I understand human nature just a bit.
When everything else is equal, the real reason someone in this scenario gets passed on is often their birth year.
Call it what it is. Then decide whether it’s costing you.
Yes, let’s talk about cost
This is the objection behind most of the others. Won’t the older candidate cost more?
Salary? Maybe. Not necessarily. Many late-career professionals have already climbed. They want meaningful work, a strong team and respect for what they know. Some will trade a bigger paycheck for flexibility. Ask. Don’t assume.
Health insurance? Potentially. Depending on your plan, an older employee can push premiums up. But their kids are often grown and off the plan. The 34-year-old may be adding a spouse and three children.
Even when the numbers do run higher, the difference is usually small. Small compared to what walks in the door with them.
What you are really buying
Pattern recognition. Thirty+ years of it. They have seen your problem before, maybe under a different name.
Judgment earned the hard way. Downturns. Reorgs. Failed launches. They made and/or experienced those mistakes on someone else’s payroll.
A network. Clients, peers and vendors who still take their call.
A faster start. Less training. Fewer expensive detours.
A teacher. Every year they are with you they pass something down to the people coming up behind them.
Try putting a price on that. Then compare it to a few thousand dollars in premiums.
Ten years is not a short time
“They’ll only be here ten years.” Listen to how that sounds.
How long do you expect the 34-year-old to stay?
Strong younger hires get recruited. They leave for the next title, the next raise, sometimes your competitor.
The candidate who says “I want one great final chapter” is giving you something rare. A timeline. You can plan the handoff. You can groom their successor. You can get every year of value out of them on purpose.
Most companies would call that a succession plan.
My point in this is simple – consider looking outside the proverbial box for your next hire.
- Don’t let “overqualified” end the conversation. Ask why they want the role.
- Put compensation on the table early. You may be surprised.
- Ask what they’ve learned in the last year. Curiosity has no age limit.
- Build knowledge transfer into the job. Decide up front who they will develop.
The real cost
The expensive hire is not the one with a slightly higher salary. It’s the one who needs two years to learn what someone else already knows.
At KMR Executive Search, we look at what a candidate brings, not when they graduated. If you’re filling a role where experience matters, let’s talk.
